On the Eve of my five day foray into New York City there is a certain song from my childhood stubbornly refusing to vacate my brain. It is Betty
Comden and Adolph Green's classic "New York, New York" from
On the Town. If, like me, you grew up in a house where at least one of the classic movie channels played 24 hours a day, it would have been pretty hard to miss the 1949 classic. Let me break down the plot: three sailors go on shore leave for one day only in New York City. They all meet women. Hilarity ensues. Oh, and they sing and dance. A lot.

Ah, to be a happy singing sailor...
Growing up in thoroughly Midwestern Minnesota, this movie inspired countless fantasies about New York. In my big apple dreams the city was exactly like a technicolor movie: friendly, glamorous and an enormous feast for the senses. Up until now, I've been in New York City three times. Have any of those trips realized my romantic vision? Let's see.
TRIP #1:
McGroarty family vacation, August 2000
Age: 14
In what was undoubtedly our most ambitious family vacation, the
McGroarty clan took an epic week long trip to the east coast with a start in New York City. My father spent most of the time preventing his three children from getting hit by cars, my mother only opted out of one trip to the theatre with a "migraine" and we managed to find our way around New York, saving our directional challenges for a three hour stint lost in rural Pennsylvania on our way to Philadelphia. The real icing on the cake was the "reality photography" phase I was going through. I had somehow gotten it into my barely teenage head that smiling for photos was something that should only be done when one was truly happy and all other photographs should depict how one was actually feeling in the moment. And because most of the pictures from this trip were taken while waiting in lines, the majority of them feature my strong older brother and adorable younger sister smiling like fools with me in the center scowling like an awkward teenager who was just told she needs head gear. One such photo is framed and displayed in our front hallway.
Verdict: Would Gene Kelly or Ann Miller scowl for a photo? Not on your life. MGM movie dream not achieved.
TRIP #2: College Visit, January 2004
Age: 17
I was dead set on a life in the theatre since I could read the audition notices in the local paper. In my mind it was the only true ticket to an adventurous life. My parents never tried to
pursuade me to try something else. Actually, that might not be true. If they did I wasn't listening. What was NOT certain was where I would be allowed to study theatre. My father and I took a trip out to New York to check out NYU and
Fordham. In retrospect I now understand that it was not my evaluation of the schools that was important, it was my father's evaluation of the city. I was not encouraged to apply.
Verdict: (College Admissions Speakers + Constant
Supervison) - Warm Weather = MGM movie dream crying on the inside.
TRIP #3: Pilgrimage to see
The American Plan, January 2008
Age: 22
The American Plan is a beautiful play written by Richard
Greenberg. I was fortunate enough to direct a production of
The American Plan while I was an undergraduate at Northwestern. Our production went up in a building called
Shanley.
Shanley is basically a shack with terrible acoustics and poles holding up the ceiling. Poles are
really great for sight lines.
Six months after graduation a revival of
The American Plan was scheduled for Broadway. My favorite play on BROADWAY! I
immediately bought my ticket. I invited my then boyfriend to tag along for the weekend trip. This was it! This was going to be the dream! My first weekend in New York City without my parents, the chance to live out my childhood fantasy!
A week before the trip I dislocated my ankle and my boyfriend dislocated his shoulder. I limped through the city streets and he schlepped around in what amounted to an almost full body arm sling. The production was terrible. If I wanted to watch family members sit around not
listening to
each other I could have taken a trip home. Making matters worse, I had scheduled the trip down to the minute. In my recent college graduate haze I was begging the universe to let me control SOMETHING in my life.
Verdict: It's difficult to frolic through the streets of New York like a singing sailor with a busted ankle and a tightly wound demeanor. MGM movie dream yet again not captured.
Three weeks ago a close friend of mine told me he was going to be in a show in New York August 5
th. I did the two things any sensible person would do: I bought a plane ticket and requested double the shifts at work to pay it off. This time there is no plan and no expectations. I'm bringing a notebook, a camera, an umbrella and some clothes. New York in 2010 is not the New York of 1949. And I'm not the girl I was at 14, or the young woman I was at 17, or even the young adult I was at 22. If anything, I think I've become
less jaded. I used to get so stressed that I might miss something, trips became all about getting the most out of every moment even at the expense of enjoying them. All I've got set right now is that tomorrow morning my plane will take off from Chicago at 7AM. Beyond that, who knows? Maybe this time I won't be so worried about living the dream and I'll be able to let my inner singing and dancing sailor spirit out on the town.